Caniba
Directed by Lucien Castaing-Taylor & Verena Paravel
2017/France

In 1981, 32-year old Japanese student Issei Sagawa murdered and ate Renée Hartevelt. Studying at the Sorbonne in Paris, Sagawa became enamoured with Hartevelt, his 25-year old classmate, while harbouring cannibalistic desires. He finally shot and ate parts of her before being caught. Found to be legally insane, charges against Sagawa were eventually dropped, and he was returned to Japan where he now lives free. Véréna Paravel and Lucien Castaing-Taylor, the documentary duo from the Harvard University Sensory Ethnography Lab, capture Issei as he currently lives with his brother Jun, in their newest film, Caniba.

In the film’s opening, we are told that the purpose of Caniba is not to legitimize Issei Sagawa’s crimes, and it is true that the film never humanizes them. Like Paravel and Castaing-Taylor’s 2012 film LeviathanCaniba is visceral, overwhelming, and alienating. Issei and Jun’s faces fill the screen in constant close-ups, with the camera going in and out of focus. Blurred at one moment, sharp at the next, we see facial features rendered like unidentifiable shadows, while then moving into clearly defined images, with every pore, hair follicle, and blemish visible upon the men’s faces. In no way does Caniba try to justify Issei’s crime, nor does it really examine it; Paravel and Castaing-Taylor opt for objectivity in their coldly distant look at the brothers, focusing on the bodily grotesque — fragmented, out of focus body parts, rhythmically pulsing lips, the too-close consumption of food are all horrifying in the straightforward presentation. The problem is the question of if this actually effective.

While avoiding a humanization of the cannibal, one wonders if it was ever an issue. Issei himself seems that he would never have wanted to be humanized in the first place, viewing himself as perverse and disgusting, while acknowledging the horror of his crimes. The film functions to give an outlet to the Sagawa brothers, possibly in the very way they want.

At one point in the film, Jun begins to discuss his own desires. We watch as he stabs his own arm with butcher knives, barbed wire, and needles, and we watch videos he has made depicting the burning, cutting, and piercing of flesh. He describes sending them to porn companies, asking for films of torture to be made with women, and being rejected as too extreme. He describes his own arousal at the pain, and his desire to view women experiencing the harm he has done to his own body. He relates this to Issei in a shocking scene that sees Jun try to seem similar to his brother who, as a literal cannibal, is less than impressed. Paired with this is a detour into a manga Issei made about his crime, drawing out the dismemberment of Hartevelt’s eroticized, nude body, paired with cartoons of himself ejaculating as he cuts up and consumes her. Jun states it should have never been published, but Issei is indifferent, expressing only that he wanted to draw.

With their “objective” gaze, Paravel and Castaing-Taylor do not comment on the Sagawa brothers, allowing them to speak their minds, simply capturing the images. Those are monstrous, grotesque close-ups, but that seems to be exactly what the Sagawas would want. At the film’s opening, we are told that because Issei cannot find work, he makes a living off of his notoriety. The manga is proof of this. So in the so-called objective look at the Sagawa brothers, is Caniba simply enabling them, and is that ethical?

In the focus on the murderer, Caniba becomes typical of the true crime genre. Over and over again we see murderers — or potential murderers — be given attention, sensitivity, and fame. Whether this be in podcasts like Serial, in television programs like Making a Murderer, in novels like In Cold Blood, or in films like Amanda Knox, what is conspicuously missing is the victims. Often women killed at the hands of men, we lose the discussion of violence against women within the depiction of violence against women by focusing on the perpetrators, or potential perpetrators. Likewise, in Caniba we watch men whose desire centres around torturing, killing, and eating women — we do not get a look into the women they have harmed, or want to harm. Instead, we get a representation of the Sagawas, in a way that they seem to be pleased with. Perhaps it is shocking to watch, but Caniba has little to it beyond that shock value. Conventional true crime made in a more formally interesting way is still conventional true crime.

The 42nd annual Toronto International Film Festival is scheduled to be held from 7 to 17 September 2017.

TIFF2017_Coverage_SordidCinema

Chelsea Phillips-Carr is a writer and film critic from Toronto.

Leave a comment below.

Latest Posts

'Firstborn' succeeds in crafting a queasy portrait of a loveless couple trapped in marriage.

Fantastic Fest 2017: ‘Maus’ Is Horror As Education

Horror has long been an excellent vehicle for political messaging, though rarely as concise and direct as in 'Maus.'
thelma_4guide_web__large

Fantastic Fest 2017: ‘Thelma’ Spins A Magical Story Of Awakening

'Thelma' is accessible, deeply human film-making about the process of growth and slippery nature of identity.

‘Steamworld Dig 2’ Review: Fracking Fun and Hole-y Engrossing

A direct sequel to the 2013’s Steamworld Dig (and less direct sequel to 2015’s Steamworld Heist), Steamworld Dig 2 is developer Image & Form’s crowning achievement.

‘JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure’: Which Story Arc Reigns Supreme?

What do muscular men flaunting flamboyance, outlandish superpowers, and villains bearing names that tribute popular musicians all have in common? They are all staple...

My First Experience With TIFF

Is the Toronto International Film Festival worth attending in person? You bet.

5 PlayStation Series We’d Love to See Return

With Sony in such a strong position at the moment and thus better placed than the competition to indulge in the odd passion project or two, wouldn’t now be the perfect time to revisit some of the platform’s former successes?
pokémon gold and silver

‘Pokémon Gold and Silver’ Remain the Greatest Pokémon Games

Pokémon Gold and Silver remain the greatest Pokémon games made to this day.

Buffyversed #29: “Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered” Lets Its Hair Down and Just Has Fun

If the second season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer shows us anything, it's a renewed sense of confidence in itself. Like its characters, Buffy is a hell of a lot more sure of itself in its second year. particularly as the season goes on. While "Halloween" showed that this show was more than willing to get silly for an episode, "Bewitched, Bewildered and Bothered" doubles down on that to glorious effect.